The Texas legislature is set to consider Senate Bill 147, a proposed law that would ban citizens of China, North Korea, Russia, and Iran from purchasing property or land in the state of Texas. Proposed by Governor Greg Abbott, this bill has been framed as an essential measure for protecting national security against foreign influences and safeguarding Texans’ constitutional freedoms. However, opponents of SB147 argue that it will have a negative impact on economic growth and job opportunities for Texans, discriminate against certain countries with large immigrant populations living within them, and send a negative message around the world. In this article we explore both sides of this debate and consider what effect this bill may have if passed into law.
Proponents’ Arguments in Favor of Senate Bill 147
Governor Abbott argues that Senate Bill 147 is necessary due to the growing ownership of Texas land by certain adversarial foreign entities. He points to the recent case of 130,000 acres near Laughlin Air Force Base in Del Rio that was purchased by a former officer of the Chinese army. According to Abbott, this bill will provide critical safeguards against authoritarian regimes who may use these acquisitions to support their own interests rather than those of stateside citizens. Supporters also believe that this legislation can make it clear that restrictions do not apply to United States citizens or lawful permanent residents regardless of country of origin.
Opponents’ Arguments Against Senate Bill 147
Despite these arguments in favor of Senate Bill 147, there are numerous individuals, businesses and organizations who are vehemently opposed to this bill. Opponents include those concerned about economic growth being impacted due to reduced foreign investment thus decreasing job opportunities for Texans; members of minority communities fearing discrimination towards certain countries with large immigrant populations living within them; protestors saying passage would send a negative message around the world; and Harris County Democratic Party Chair Odus Evbagharu condemning it as a racist and xenophobic law indicative of right-wing extremism.
Some worry that if passed, SB147 could severely hurt the Texas economy by discouraging potential investments from certain nations and reducing international trade relationships between Texas and other countries. Those against the bill are calling it racist because they feel that it unfairly targets immigrants from certain adversarial nations while ignoring other foreign investors who may pose similar risks.
Public Response & Amended Proposals
Public protests have broken out in response to Senate Bill 147 with many individuals speaking out both for and against its passage. Fort Bend County Judge KP George voiced his opposition stating “It’s not about Texas… It’s America.” On the other hand supporters such as Texas Senator Lois Kolkhurst argued that this law is necessary for preserving national security and protecting Texans’ constitutional freedoms. After receiving feedback from the Asian community, she plans to amend the bill so that it does not prohibit legal permanent U.S. residents from buying property in Texas—building upon SB 2116 which passed unanimously in 2021—and make clear that prohibitions do not apply to citizens and lawful permanent US residents.
Senate Bill 147 (SB 147) proposes a ban on individuals and organizations from certain countries—including China, North Korea, Russia and Iran—from purchasing real estate in Texas within a mile-and-a-half radius of any military base or facility. Exemptions are included for those with valid visas or green cards.
Governor Abbott believes this bill is necessary to protect national interests against foreign influences who may pose a threat to our nation’s security through espionage activities or other malicious acts towards our military installations.
Supporters include many legislators recognizing the importance of protecting military investments and infrastructure against hostile foreign actors as well as veteran’s groups hoping their service will be remembered for generations through protection via legislative action like SB147.
Opponents view this legislation as nothing more than thinly veiled racism aimed at immigrants from these four countries unfairly targeting innocent civilians based off perceived political affiliations rather than actual criminal activity.
On one hand, if enacted, businesses fear that restricting access to real estate will make it harder for immigrants from these nations to settle into life in Texas which could potentially harm economic productivity due to lack integration. On the other hand, passing such legislation may prevent harmful interference by hostile forces while discouraging future immigration which may both help strengthen local economies by reducing competition for jobs.
Conclusion & Outlook
As debate continues over how best to protect national security without infringing on civil liberties or inhibiting economic growth, only time will tell whether Senate Bill 147 passes into law or fails in its mission to protect Texans from foreign threats while respecting their rights under our Constitution. In conclusion it remains unclear what effect Senate Bill 147 will have on immigration language translation services; Chinese-speaking, Russian-speaking, and Farsi speaking communities; mortgage companies, business investments; and more should it pass into law. As debates continue over how best safeguard national security without infringing on civil liberties or inhibiting economic growth, we urge all readers pay close attention developments surrounding this issue and contact your elected officials today express concerns you may have about SB147 before voting begins later next year.
How SB147 Might Effect Business in Texas
The effect of the proposed law on translation services in Texas remains uncertain. As the debate over Senate Bill 147 continues, 24 Hour Translation Services encourages all readers to pay close attention to developments surrounding this issue and contact elected officials to express any concerns they may have about SB147. Senate Bill 147 could potentially impact 24 Hour Translation Services and other similar companies by reducing the number of immigrants from these countries who are able to settle into life in Texas, which could potentially affect economic productivity. Additionally, with several consulates in Houston, including the Honorary Consulate of Russia and the Consulate-General of China, the bill may result in reduced business investments and international trade relationships between Texas and other countries. The passing of the bill may also create a negative message around the world, impacting translation services in Texas.
Contact us – 24 Hour Translation Services 2020 Montrose Blvd. #202, Houston, TX 76006 | 5025 Addison Circle, Addison, TX. 75001